How Kenya ICT Board Kills the Spirit of Tech Innovators and Content Generators

Posted In Technology - By robertalai On Monday, June 20th, 2011 With 18 Comments

Kukubo How Kenya ICT Board Kills the Spirit of Tech Innovators and Content Generators

This post is inspired by the spirit of transparency as enshrined in the new constitution. So please nobody should hold it against me nor take it personal. When the voice of the voiceless is dimmed with shouts of traitor! traitor! , we take it upon ourselves to sneak it through this medium and make sure that it is heard loud enough.

We must first acknowledge that the Kenyan government through ICT Board is trying in various ways to market the country’s ICT potential as well as help techies look for opportunities elsewhere around the world. Through the seminars, conferences and informal meetups all over, the ICT Board has at-least made a move to show that they can work. But it is not even above average effort according to me. The hype is just around a few people in Nairobi and not even the middle class communities of techies have been fully roped into the tech idea.

You want to know how Kenya ICT Board stands accused? Read below;

1. Favoritism and Class of Winners Around Paul Kukubo and Key ICT Board Managers

This issue has been a bone of contention of many Kenyans who are into ICT. Many of the trailblazers in tech in Kenya who works freelance  developers, engineers and systems analysts have been locked out of key meetings of Kenya ICT Board. We have very many Kenyans who did set up or trained in such firms as Africa Online, Aptech, IS, Fintech and even Symphony but are now mostly freelaancing.

The fact that they like things formal and have not had a chance to bulldoze their way into the office of Paul Kukubo has meant that they are locked out from key events. There is a feeling within Kenya ICT Board that the few mailing lists individuals runs are the best advertising avenues. They then leave out those whom because they have contrary opinions, have been left out of the mailingg lists. Whenever you have had a contest, it has first been shared within the circle of friends of former 3 Mice and Paul Kukubo and then the immediate friends whom Kukubo has worked with on projects.

That is how you will find same individuals sit on judging panels of Pasha and Local Content. They have no other qualification apart from having a basic education and being the friends of the right people. You will learn why below. And even the media nowadays they invite first channels run by friends of Kukubo. I have heard confessions from friends who work with such channels and tells me that Paul Kukubo called them personally to go cover such events while Kenya ICT Board supposedly maintains a media mailing list which they rarely used.

2. Management at ICT Board / Ignorance and Poor Judging of Key Contests

You have seen ICT Board call for proposals for the local contents and the Pasha centres loans. First the Local Contents grant was a poorly organised and executed idea that it smells strongly of fraud. Friends of Kaburo Kobia, Paul Kukubo and key personnel at Kenya ICT Board were called and informed that what was needed was a mobile application and not necessarily a content of any nature. So we have found out that firms were set up for the competition with mobile platforms generated using app wizards for mainly Nokia’s OVI store.

The app platforms were later hyped by Paul Kukubo and Kaburo Kobia with the other Tandaa proponents through the tech talks. 90% of the entities and platforms presented by the winners are non-existent just less than one year later. Many applicants who have been generating contents years before even the idea of rewarding content generators was mooted are asking if it was a contest to reward for content or for platforms. We talked to 3 organisation which applied for the funds and they say that when they contacted Kaburo Kobia to ask what was the criteria because none of those awarded had content, Kaburo called them “loud mouthed bitches who were mourning over a missed opportunity”.

And some of the judging in contests like digital content grant contest were also questioned with those who were shortlisting asking why Jessica Colaco and Professor Thairu were on the panel? None of them have done any serious content they cant talk about. Prof. Thairu is an educationist and Jessica Colaco is a mobile developer. So you find like one of the judges called Kenya Buzz before the shortlisting and asked them that the panel would be looking for a mobile app. The Kenya Buzz team jumped on the idea and immediately generated a mobile app and they won the grant. Almost one year down the line, they don’t have the content they won the grant for. Their mobile apps are a sketch of what the grant could do.

And so the Kenya Buzz directors who are all British, Alix Grubel, Marta and Nicholas saw it as an opportunity to get a piece of the Kenyan pie which they were invited to taste. Not that the money made any difference to them considering that they are doing consultancies in various fields and from the physical magazine they could also generate enough money to develop a better mobile app for iOS, Windows or Symbian phones but they just don’t see a better market there yet. This is just but one example.

3. All Kenya ICT Board Concentrated in Nairobi

The duty of preaching the ICT evangelism has been left to poorly equipped college graduates who travel upcountry and will not have good internet connection or sometimes even a laptop to keep in touch. Kenya ICT Board has jumped onto the bus of iHub and you would think that Kenyan government built the iHub. Instead of harnessing such synergies regionally, Paul Kukubo and his gang are resting on his laurels and relying on the empty buzz the Kenyan techies have created online to chest thump and claim rewards.

Not much effort is being put into listening to Kenyans in Mandera, Eldoret, Kakamega, Kisii or even Mombasa to understand where there problems lie in promoting the use of ICT. You can imagine what the amount being used to host 50 or so people in Serena can do in a place like Kisii in promoting ICT. If Kenya ICT Board was to hold such a meeting, they would transport all the layabouts from Nairobi to Kisii for sight seeing and off the city tours.

4. Contrary Opinion is from the Devil

If you dare speak ill of the efforts of Kenya ICT Board managers, you will be blacklisted from key events, bad mouthed and even given secret labels from the mongrels kept to bark and earn their keep through the joomla and wordpress installation projects marketed around as web design assignments. Dare ask Paul Kukubo a question on any of the mailing lists and you will see how many of the mongrels will jump on your neck and accuse you of all manner of things including “plotting to kill the good manager”.

To better the workings at Kenya ICT Board and other state organs, contrary opinion MUST be listened to. It is not a matter of being holier-than-thou Himself but these are state funds.

We will be updating this post as time goes by but you can comment below on what you feel about the Kenyan ICT Board and its operations.

About - Robert is an African Tech Blogger, Critic, Net Evangelist, Speaker, Mentor for Young Boys and Girls, Editor @TechMtaa and likes to Provide Sanitary Towels To Poor Women through the DishAPad Initiative

  • Guest

    Pretty strong accusations. But measured for results, the Local content grant to Kenyabuzz was farcical. The company is wholly owned by foreigners/expats and so should not have been eligible in the first place. Any arguments citing the quality of applicants (as some rumblings suggested & hence the award to a foreign owned firm) is to completely defeat the point of the awards since the grants were to develop local talent. Plus yet to see what they did with the grant!

  • Antowus

    WRITE PROPER ENGLISH, PLEASE.

    • http://www.techmtaa.com Nyokwongi

      I wonder if you have even a single sentence you have written anywhere. Just me wondering

    • http://www.techmtaa.com Nyokwongi

      I wonder if you have even a single sentence you have written anywhere. Just me wondering

    • Sueddy

      You are another bad mouthed individual. How do you even write a sentence in Caps and yet claim to be the grammar judge. You even do not listen to what Robert has to say coz I think there are a lot of points u missed while looking for grammatical mistakes.

    • Sueddy

      You are another bad mouthed individual. How do you even write a sentence in Caps and yet claim to be the grammar judge. You even do not listen to what Robert has to say coz I think there are a lot of points u missed while looking for grammatical mistakes.

  • Antowus

    WRITE PROPER ENGLISH, PLEASE.

  • http://twitter.com/crystalintmedia Crystalint Media

    Hey Robert, where can we run to when things like Pasha go awry? KACC or CCK? Is there a body that governs the conduct of KICT Board or any ICT organization for that matter?

  • Pingback: ICTD.de » Nairobi, Kenya: Africa’s New Tech Hub?

  • Guest

    Nice post. Why is ICT board made up of people who worked at 3mice before, does it mean other Kenyans were not capable. I know someone with a Strong ICT background,knowledge management and society issues who would a good replacement to Kaburo. Someone who is highly regarded in her Scholarly work and research. Such people should be in ICT board!
    On the grants issue, those allocated the money should have accounted for every penny.
    I see a new form of colonialism in the ICT sector where foreigners come and want to take over and step on our shoes. It is not that we do not want them to invest in Kenya but they should not be treated better just because they are white. Kenyan firms should be supported also.

  • Guest

    Nice post. Why is ICT board made up of people who worked at 3mice before, does it mean other Kenyans were not capable. I know someone with a Strong ICT background,knowledge management and society issues who would a good replacement to Kaburo. Someone who is highly regarded in her Scholarly work and research. Such people should be in ICT board!
    On the grants issue, those allocated the money should have accounted for every penny.
    I see a new form of colonialism in the ICT sector where foreigners come and want to take over and step on our shoes. It is not that we do not want them to invest in Kenya but they should not be treated better just because they are white. Kenyan firms should be supported also.

  • Cathyannmurungi

    Very disappointing indeed. How can an entire county like Bungoma not qualify for a single Pasha Centre? I saw one of the Biz plans of one applicant and it was very very impressive given his little exposure to ICT as a rural folk in Kimilili constituency.
    Cathy.

  • Barmuriat

    I do not ussually agree  with you hilltop ‘screams’ but today you have it the nail on the head.ICT-Board is a group of late 90s comp science graduate groopies who cling together in their palatial offices and plot on how to ‘eat’ ICT govt money by holding conferences and tours to Silicon Valley.I applied for Tandaa Digital Village Grant 4yrs ago was shorlisted but never heard on the winners yet? .I think KUKUBO should just move his office to Turkana so that he can clearly understand and picture the REAL needs of content for solving socio-economic and political disparities in this country.

    • http://www.techmtaa.com Robert Alai

      I don’t expect you to agree with me especially when I roast an ethnic kingpin you so much adore. Thanks for todays support

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/James-G-Mbugua/618777592 James G. Mbugua

    I would personally like the ICT Board to be audited for how it spends its money. Particularly, the money it has sent on the CEOs travels to far flung cities apparently to market Kenya. Why can’t they use that money to bring those techies from Silicon Valley here to meet with local techpreneurs? I think the whole board should be disbanded and a fresh team competitively sought.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/IFWQBDMVHYNLGDWLHP7UIAXRUI Robert

    Hi namesake,

    It is good to see that someone has the guts to take on the establishment, two years ago I asked on KICTANET “Who is the ICT Board?” and has you have mentioned the dogs where released and I got mauled thoroughly.

    It is my hope that the issues raised will be followed through to the logical conclusion, keep up the posts.

  • http://twitter.com/Mwangy Mark Mwangi

    I also don’t often agree with your mostly sensational posts but this one has hit home. These guys have little to show for all these said competitions and the infamous capacity building. When confronted about the work on the attorney generals site concerning searching of company names, dodging and shifting blame was the order of the day. The company awarded the contract was 3mice and to date even search functionality (primary business of the site ) doesn’t work. 

    We don’t need fancy apps that hardly actually help most Kenyans.

  • Mjamme

    These ICT Boards in Africa are the point of entry and reference for investors, businesses, and organisations looking to understand industry spectrums in Africa. If we cannot trust their transparency, accountability then we have a serious problem as a continent. Africa is suffering from negative narratives exactly because of the dreadful attitudes of the people we trust to represent our interests. The people behind powerful organisations using power, favouritism, nepotism, tribalism, selective relationships to get access to contracts, good- temporary media coverage or deals are putting their communities down and to one mile their own country. Food for thought. Whatever we do must benefit the community around us if it does not then we must look again and do the RIGHT thing…Finally we must be true to ourselves. Always!! @mjamme